Table of Contents
Jacky Cheung and his wife were blacklisted by Filipino maids
Jacky Cheung and his wifeMay LoRecently, due to frequent changes of Filipino maids, the Philippine Consulate General in Hong Kong listed it as a "Blacklist of people prohibited from hiring Filipino maids", sparking heated public debate. This incident not only involves the transnational labor rights protection mechanism, but also reflects the complex contradiction between celebrity family privacy and foreign domestic worker management. With the Philippines releasing details of its employment records, May Lo's unsuccessful visit to the consulate to negotiate, and many Hong Kong artists from the entertainment industry expressing their support, the dispute has escalated from a private dispute to a social issue.
Dismissal within three years21 Filipino maids, touching the Philippines' employment red line
According to the records of the Labour Affairs Department of the Philippine Consulate General in Hong Kong, Jacky Cheung and his wife hired a total of 21 Filipino maids in the past three years. Only a few of them completed the two-year contract, and most of them terminated the contract early. The former Filipino maid Catacutan even accused me of being the 60th one to be kicked out!
Although May Lo explained that "because she employed four Filipino maids at the same time, the number of replacements seemed large", the Philippines determined that her employment model was abnormal and violated the principle of "reasonable replacement", and therefore blacklisted the two. Currently, the four Filipino maids employed by the Zhang family are not allowed to renew their contracts after the expiration of the ban, and the time of lifting the ban is unclear.
Philippine Consul General Al Vicente emphasized that this move was not a retaliation for the "Filipino maid stealing letters case" at the end of 2022 (the maid in the case was originally sentenced to six months, but was reduced after appeal), but was based on objective data evaluation. The official statement solemnly pointed out that the relevant administrative sanctions were purely in accordance with the standardized review procedures of labor contracts and had no causal relationship with the outcomes of any judicial cases.
Experts exclaim: Excessive cleaning is harmful to your health!
According to insiders, in order to maintain a "zero pollution" living space, May Lo customized a devilish cleaning process, and basic daily cleaning requires the use of three Filipino maids to work in shifts for 18 hours!
A professor of microbiology at the University of Hong Kong warned of this phenomenon: "Long-term exposure to a sterile environment will weaken the immune system, and excessive use of chemical disinfectants is more likely to cause respiratory diseases." How can her family adapt to this "sterile cage" life!
Luo Meiwei went to the consulate to negotiate and cry for the lifting of the ban
The monthly magazine "Filipino Globe" also revealed that May Lo had met with Vicente and other Philippine officials in early September to explain that the number of layoffs was exaggerated, and said that "if other families hired four maids, the turnover rate would also be high." However, Philippine media also quoted sources as saying that May Lo "cried and begged for the blacklist to be removed but to no avail."
It is worth noting that foreign domestic worker contracts in Hong Kong are regulated by the Standard Employment Contract. If the employer terminates the contract early, he or she must pay wages in lieu of notice and return air tickets, but there is no clear limit on the number of dismissals. The blacklist mechanism of the Philippine Consulate is actually an "informal protection" of overseas workers by the mother country, attempting to check the power of employers through administrative means.
Institutional Dilemma: Blacklist Mechanism vs. Employer Autonomy
Although the blacklist system of the Philippine Consulate has no legal force, it actually affects the willingness of Filipino domestic helpers. According to statistics from the Hong Kong Foreign Domestic Workers Employers Association, about 151 TP3T employers were rejected by agencies due to "excessive dismissal" and were included in the official blacklist.Very rare. This incident reflects the Philippines' sensitivity to "abnormal dismissal rates". The considerations behind this include:
- Labor Rights Protection: Frequent dismissals may involve improper treatment, and the Philippines needs to prevent its citizens from becoming "unwashed laborers";
- Maintaining diplomatic image: High-profile cases may damage the international reputation of Filipino domestic workers as "reliable and hardworking";
- Intermediary industry interests：Stable contracts can reduce administrative costs and protect the long-term profits of brokers.
However, this mechanism has also sparked controversy over "excessive interference with employment freedom." Hong Kong legal professionals pointed out that the Philippines has no right to restrict Hong Kong people from hiring foreign domestic helpers, but in practice it can indirectly ban it by delaying document review. The power game in this gray area may become the fuse for future labor-management conflicts.
A microcosm of transnational labor politics: the structural contradictions of Hong Kong’s migrant worker ecosystem
There are more than 340,000 foreign domestic helpers in Hong Kong, of which 52% are from the Philippines. They are subject to the Immigration Ordinance and must live with their employers, are not allowed to work part-time, and must leave the country within two weeks after the expiration of their contract. This system, which combines "temporary" and "dependent" characteristics, puts foreign domestic workers in a structural disadvantage.
The Jacky Cheung incident highlights two major issues:
- Power imbalance: Employers can dismiss domestic workers at their own will, and there is no complaint buffer mechanism for domestic workers;
- Cultural friction: Celebrity families view foreign domestic workers as a “source of privacy risk”, while domestic workers may cross the line out of curiosity or financial temptation.
Scholars suggest that the government should promote "pre-employment psychological training for foreign domestic workers" to help them adapt to high-pressure working environments, while requiring employers to participate in management courses to reduce cultural misunderstandings.
Further reading:
